published on in blog

Film Review: Perfect Obedience

Juan Manuel Bernal acts up a storm as the corrupt spiritual leader of a Catholic seminary in this elegantly salacious tale of priestly pedophilia.

Mexican helmer Luiz Urquiza’s debut feature, “Perfect Obedience,” examines the pedophilic relationship between the spiritual leader of a Catholic seminary and the comely, naive young lad he selects as his newest disciple. Attempting both to validate the affair from the young seminarian’s p.o.v. and to condemn the hypocrisy of the corrupt priest, the film’s conflicting agendas wind up canceling each other out in an uneasy amalgam of pious devotion and heavy breathing. This winner of the top prize at Montreal has proven hugely popular at home, its explosive subject matter, powerful thesping and elegant lensing elevating what might otherwise be described as tasteful salaciousness.

The fictional Father Angel de la Cruz (Juan Manuel Bernal) is based on Legion of Christ founder Marcial Maciel, whose long history of child abuse was addressed only in 2006 and publicly acknowledged in 2009. But Urquiza chooses to structure his film through the largely uncomprehending, wondering eyes of 13-year-old Julian (Sebastian Aguirre Boeda), who travels from the arms of his loving pastoral family into the hallowed halls of the seminary, its austere opulence masking a hotbed of homosexuality. Singling out the attractive boy as his intimate disciple, installing him in his palatial private quarters and redubbing him Sacramento Santos, Father Angel begins Julian’s instruction into the mysteries of “perfect obedience,” whose cardinal rule is: Never question a superior’s actions.

Related Stories

concert crowd and stock arrow VIP+

New Live Music Data Suggests Cautious Optimism

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - FEBRUARY 26: Sally Field attends the 29th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards at Fairmont Century Plaza on February 26, 2023 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Frazer Harrison/Getty Images)

Sally Field Details Her 'Traumatic' and 'Hideous' Illegal Abortion From 1964 to Urge Voters to Elect Kamala Harris: 'We Can't Go Back'

Urquiza stresses the fundamental prepubescent heterosexuality of the young seminarians, who have no complicity whatsoever in the dubious practices going on around them, even when they are the victims. The same certainly cannot be said of the community of priests, exchanging knowing glances and leeringly encouraging sexual details in confession, turning disappointed when the boys’ fantasies feature women instead of men.

Popular on Variety

No one could accuse Urquiza of subtlety, though he is careful to avoid any graphic depiction or physical manifestation of pedophilia. But Father Angel’s swooning breathlessness as he washes Julian’s feet in a church ritual speaks volumes. In addition to his abuse of children, Angel’s proclivities extend to whores and heroin; should anyone miss the diabolical point, the priest is shown drunkenly dancing to the strains of “Sympathy for the Devil.”

Young Boeda succeeds admirably in casting his beatific good looks in a postcard-perfect saintly light, and Alejandro de Hoyos, as Angel’s former acolyte, brings some much-needed complexity and resonance into the mix. But the film belongs to Bernal as he effortlessly extends his evangelical charisma to encompass the most outrageous of perversions.

Serguei Saldivar Tanaka’s lensing heightens the contrast between the dignified beauty of the seminary compound and the increasingly unholy activities it harbors.

Jump to Comments

Film Review: ‘Perfect Obedience’

Reviewed at Montreal World Film Festival (competing), Aug. 31, 2014. Running time: 99 MIN. (Original title: “Obediencia perfecta”)

  • Production: (Mexico) A Latam Pictures (in Mexico) release of an Astillero Films production. Produced by Lourdes Garcia, Luis Urquiza.
  • Crew: Directed by Luis Urquiza. Screenplay, Ernesto Alcocer, Urquiza. Camera (color, 16mm/35mm), Serguei Saldivar Tanaka; editor, Jorge Macaya; music, Alejandro Giacoman; music supervisor, Herminio Gutierrez; sound designer (Dolby digital), Miguel Angel Molina; casting, Camila Selser, Margarita Mandoki.
  • With: Juan Manuel Bernal, Sebastian Aguirre Boeda, Alejandro de Hoyos, Juan Ignacio Aranda, Luis Ernesto Franco.

More from Variety

Most Popular

Must Read

Sign Up for Variety Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Variety Confidential

ncG1vNJzZmiukae2psDYZ5qopV9nfXKAjp%2BgpaVfm7K0wMivmKWrX5u2rbmMq5yvoZWserGx0Z%2BcnKxdpK%2BmsMiepZydXWZ%2FcX2SaWxvbmBk